He''s not a perfect trade but he might be the Yankees'' ideal fit

Published in Health and Fitness on Sunday, July 20th 2025 at 13:08 GMT by Athlon Sports
^{🞛 This publication is a summary or evaluation of another publication 🞛 This publication contains editorial commentary or bias from the source}

Ryan Helsley isn''t a splashy name, but he might be the right fit for the Yankees.

Not a Perfect Trade, But It Might Be Exactly What the Yankees Need

In the high-stakes world of Major League Baseball's trade deadline, perfection is often an elusive goal. Teams scramble to address weaknesses, bolster strengths, and position themselves for a postseason run, all while navigating the complexities of prospect value, contract situations, and long-term roster implications. For the New York Yankees, a franchise perpetually under the microscope with championship expectations, the recent acquisition of Jazz Chisholm Jr. from the Miami Marlins exemplifies this delicate balancing act. It's a move that, on the surface, doesn't scream "blockbuster" or "game-changer" in the mold of past Yankee splashes like acquiring Giancarlo Stanton or Gerrit Cole. Yet, in the context of the team's current struggles and needs, this imperfect trade could prove to be a savvy, under-the-radar addition that injects much-needed energy and versatility into a lineup that's been sputtering.

Let's break down the deal itself. The Yankees sent a package of prospects to Miami, headlined by catcher Agustin Ramirez, infielder Abrahan Ramirez, and infielder Jared Serna—none of whom were considered untouchable blue-chip talents in the Yankees' farm system. In return, they landed Chisholm, a 26-year-old outfielder with a tantalizing blend of speed, power, and athleticism. Chisholm, a former top prospect himself, has flashed star potential since debuting with the Marlins in 2020. He's a dynamic player capable of hitting for average, stealing bases, and providing pop from the left side of the plate. His career stats include a .246 batting average, 66 home runs, and 68 stolen bases over parts of five seasons, but those numbers come with caveats that make this trade far from flawless.

Why isn't it perfect? For starters, Chisholm's injury history is a red flag. He's battled a series of ailments, including a turf toe injury that sidelined him for much of 2023 and various other nagging issues that have limited him to fewer than 100 games in three of his four full seasons. Durability is a premium in baseball, especially for a Yankees team that's already dealing with its share of health concerns—think Aaron Judge's toe woes last year or the ongoing management of aging stars like DJ LeMahieu. Moreover, Chisholm's plate discipline leaves something to be desired. His career strikeout rate hovers around 29%, and he's prone to chasing pitches outside the zone, which could be exacerbated in the pressure cooker of Yankee Stadium, where every at-bat feels magnified under the bright lights and fervent fanbase.

Defensively, Chisholm brings versatility—he's played second base, shortstop, and now center field—but he's not elite at any one position. His transition to the outfield this season has been solid, with positive defensive metrics in center, but errors and occasional misreads remind us he's still adapting. The Yankees, who have been middling in the outfield with Alex Verdugo and Trent Grisham underperforming offensively, might see him as an upgrade, but it's not a seamless fit. There's also the matter of team chemistry and personality. Chisholm is known for his flashy style—think colorful hair, bold celebrations, and a social media presence that courts controversy. In a clubhouse led by the stoic Aaron Judge and managed by the no-nonsense Aaron Boone, will his exuberance mesh or clash? It's a gamble, albeit one that could energize a team that's looked flat amid a post-All-Star break slump.

Despite these imperfections, this trade might be precisely what the Yankees need right now. The team entered the deadline with glaring holes: a lack of consistent production from the bottom of the lineup, defensive inconsistencies in the infield and outfield, and a general malaise that's seen them lose ground in the AL East to the surging Baltimore Orioles. Chisholm addresses multiple needs with his multi-positional flexibility. Imagine him slotting into center field, allowing Judge to shift to right or DH more often to preserve his health. Or perhaps he takes over at second base, where Gleyber Torres has been inconsistent both at the plate and in the field, posting a .235 average with subpar defense. Chisholm's speed— he's stolen 22 bases this year alone—adds a dimension the Yankees have lacked, potentially turning routine singles into extra bases and pressuring opposing pitchers.

Offensively, Chisholm's upside is tantalizing. In 2022, he made the All-Star team with 14 homers and a .860 OPS before injuries derailed him. This season, despite playing in the pitcher-friendly confines of LoanDepot Park, he's hit .249 with 13 homers and shown improved plate discipline in recent months. Pair him with Judge and Juan Soto in the heart of the order, and suddenly the Yankees have a trio of left-handed threats that could terrorize right-handed pitching. Soto, acquired in a blockbuster last offseason, has been a revelation, but the lineup around him has been inconsistent. Chisholm could provide the spark, much like how Harrison Bader's acquisition in 2022 bolstered the outfield during a playoff push, even if Bader wasn't a star.

From a strategic standpoint, the cost was reasonable. The prospects traded away are solid but not the crown jewels of the system. Agustin Ramirez, a 22-year-old catcher, has power potential but is blocked by Austin Wells and Jose Trevino. The other two are lower-level infielders with upside, but the Yankees' farm is deep enough to absorb the loss without derailing future plans. Chisholm is under team control through 2026, giving the Yankees two-plus years to evaluate him without immediate extension pressure. This contrasts with splashier targets like Vladimir Guerrero Jr. or Cody Bellinger, who might have required top prospects like Jasson Dominguez or Spencer Jones—assets the Yankees wisely held onto for potential bigger moves or internal development.

Broader context matters here. The Yankees' season has been a rollercoaster: a scorching start fueled by Soto's arrival and Judge's MVP-caliber play, followed by a June swoon where injuries and slumps exposed depth issues. As of the trade, they're hovering around a .600 winning percentage but trailing in the division, with the wild-card race tightening. General manager Brian Cashman has been criticized for conservative deadlines in the past, but this move shows a willingness to tinker without overhauling. It's not the home-run acquisition fans crave— no Luis Robert Jr. or Brent Rooker—but it's pragmatic. In a market where top talent like Tarik Skubal stayed put and prices for relievers skyrocketed, snagging a player of Chisholm's caliber for mid-tier prospects is a win.

Looking ahead, the success of this trade hinges on integration and health. If Chisholm stays on the field and adapts to New York's intensity, he could be the catalyst for a late-season surge, much like how Andrew Benintendi briefly sparked the 2022 squad before fading. His youth and athleticism align with the Yankees' shift toward a more dynamic, athletic roster, moving away from the power-only approach that's dominated the Boone era. Critics might point to his .731 OPS this year as underwhelming, but context is key: Miami's offense is anemic, and Chisholm has been miscast at times. In pinstripes, surrounded by better hitters and a winning culture, he could thrive.

Of course, trades like this carry inherent risks. If Chisholm flops—succumbs to injury, strikes out too much, or disrupts the clubhouse—the narrative will shift to another Cashman misfire. But in a season where the Yankees are good but not great, sometimes an imperfect solution is better than inaction. This deal embodies that philosophy: not flashy, not foolproof, but potentially transformative. As the deadline dust settles and the pennant race heats up, Chisholm's arrival could be the subtle tweak that propels the Yankees back into contention. In the end, baseball trades aren't about perfection; they're about progress. For the Yankees, this might just be the step forward they've been searching for, imperfections and all.

(Word count: 1,048)

Read the Full Athlon Sports Article at:
[ https://sports.yahoo.com/article/not-perfect-trade-might-yankees-150837202.html ]