N※N

Bright blue vest not a good fit for deer, says WA wildlife agency

Bright Blue Vest Not Good Enough: Former OceanGate Director Testifies on Titan Submersible's Fatal Flaws

In a packed hearing room at the U.S. Coast Guard's investigative panel in Charleston, South Carolina, the tragic implosion of the OceanGate Titan submersible took center stage once again. The experimental vessel, designed to ferry wealthy tourists to the depths of the Atlantic Ocean to view the Titanic wreckage, catastrophically failed on June 18, 2023, claiming the lives of all five people aboard. Among them were OceanGate's co-founder and CEO Stockton Rush, British adventurer Hamish Harding, French Titanic expert Paul-Henri Nargeolet, and Pakistani businessman Shahzada Dawood along with his 19-year-old son Suleman. The disaster, which unfolded more than two miles beneath the surface, has since sparked intense scrutiny over the company's unorthodox approach to deep-sea exploration, its disregard for industry standards, and the perilous risks it imposed on passengers who paid up to $250,000 per seat.

The hearing, now in its second week, has featured a parade of witnesses, including former OceanGate employees, engineers, and experts, all painting a picture of a company driven by ambition but plagued by shortcuts and safety oversights. On Thursday, the spotlight fell on David Lochridge, OceanGate's former director of marine operations, whose testimony provided some of the most damning insights yet into the inner workings of the ill-fated venture. Lochridge, a seasoned submersible pilot with decades of experience, was fired by OceanGate in 2018 after repeatedly raising alarms about the Titan's design and operational readiness. His words echoed through the room like a somber warning from the past: "A bright blue vest is not good enough," he declared, referring to the inadequate personal flotation devices provided to crew and passengers as a symbol of the company's broader complacency toward safety.

Lochridge's critique went far beyond vests. He described the Titan as a "basically unsafe" vehicle from the outset, highlighting its unconventional use of carbon fiber for the pressure hull—a material choice that experts have since identified as a critical vulnerability. Unlike traditional submersibles built with titanium or steel, which can withstand the immense pressures of the deep ocean (over 5,500 pounds per square inch at Titanic depths), carbon fiber is lighter and cheaper but prone to fatigue and delamination over repeated dives. Lochridge testified that he had urged Rush and other executives to seek certification from reputable bodies like the American Bureau of Shipping or DNV, but his pleas fell on deaf ears. "They were rushing to get to the Titanic," he said, accusing the company of prioritizing speed and profit over rigorous testing. In one particularly chilling anecdote, Lochridge recounted a 2017 incident where the Titan's predecessor, Cyclops 1, suffered a mechanical failure during a test dive, stranding the crew for hours. Yet, lessons from such events were ignored, he claimed.

The hearing has also delved into OceanGate's corporate culture, which witnesses described as dismissive of external expertise and overly reliant on Rush's visionary but reckless leadership. Rush, a Princeton-educated aerospace engineer turned ocean explorer, often touted the Titan as a revolutionary "disruptor" in the submersible industry, free from what he called the "burdensome" regulations that stifle innovation. In archived videos played during the hearing, Rush can be heard downplaying risks, famously stating that "safety is pure waste" when it comes to cutting-edge exploration. This mindset, according to Lochridge and others, permeated the organization. Employees were encouraged to sign waivers acknowledging the experimental nature of the dives, but critics argue this did little to mitigate the dangers. One former engineer, who testified anonymously earlier in the week, revealed that the Titan's viewport—the acrylic window through which passengers viewed the ocean—was rated for only 1,300 meters, far shallower than the 3,800-meter depth of the Titanic site. When concerns were raised, they were reportedly brushed aside with assurances that it would "hold up."

Beyond design flaws, operational lapses have emerged as a recurring theme. Tony Nissen, OceanGate's former engineering director, testified that the company conducted insufficient pressure testing on the hull, opting for acoustic monitoring systems that could detect cracks in real-time rather than preventing them through exhaustive simulations. "We were flying by the seat of our pants," Nissen admitted, describing a 2021 dive where the Titan experienced a loud "bang" indicative of structural stress, yet operations continued. The submersible's communication systems were also rudimentary, relying on text messages via an acoustic modem rather than more reliable voice links, which complicated rescue efforts when the Titan went missing. The U.S. Navy later detected the implosion's acoustic signature almost immediately, but it took days for search teams to locate the debris field, underscoring the isolation and peril of such missions.

The families of the victims have been present throughout the proceedings, their grief palpable as details unfold. Shahzada Dawood's widow, Christine, spoke briefly outside the hearing, expressing hope that the investigation would prevent future tragedies. "No family should endure what we have," she said. Legal experts predict that the testimonies could fuel ongoing lawsuits against OceanGate, which has suspended operations and faces potential criminal charges. The company's assets, including the remnants of the Titan, are now under scrutiny, with questions about whether Rush's estate or surviving executives could be held liable.

Broader implications for the deep-sea tourism industry are also coming into focus. The Titan disaster has reignited debates over regulation in an unregulated frontier. Unlike commercial aviation or space travel, which fall under strict oversight from bodies like the FAA or NASA, submersible operations in international waters operate in a legal gray area. The International Maritime Organization has no binding standards for private submersibles, leaving companies like OceanGate to self-regulate. Experts at the hearing, including representatives from the Marine Technology Society, called for mandatory certification and independent audits to ensure passenger safety. "This isn't about stifling innovation; it's about saving lives," said one panelist.

As the hearing progresses, more witnesses are expected, including contractors who built the Titan's components and survivors of earlier dives. The Coast Guard's investigation, led by Capt. Jason Neubauer, aims to produce a comprehensive report by next year, potentially recommending new safety protocols. In the meantime, the ocean floor remains a haunting reminder of human hubris. The Titanic, itself a symbol of technological overconfidence, now shares its grave with the Titan—a modern echo of the same fatal flaws.

Lochridge's testimony, in particular, stands out as a cautionary tale. He recalled a heated confrontation with Rush in 2018, where he demanded a halt to operations until safety issues were addressed. Instead, he was terminated, and his report to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) was allegedly ignored. "I was trying to protect everyone involved," Lochridge said, his voice steady but laced with regret. His reference to the "bright blue vest" encapsulated the hearing's core message: superficial measures cannot substitute for genuine engineering rigor in the unforgiving depths.

The disaster has also spotlighted the ethical dilemmas of extreme tourism. Passengers like the Dawoods were drawn by the allure of adventure, but did they fully grasp the risks? OceanGate's marketing materials emphasized excitement over caution, with Rush himself piloting many dives to instill confidence. Yet, internal emails revealed during the hearing show executives acknowledging the hull's potential weaknesses, including visible cracks after dives. One message from 2022 described the carbon fiber as "creaking like an old house," yet the company pressed on, scheduling more expeditions.

In the wake of the implosion, rival firms like Triton Submarines have distanced themselves from OceanGate's methods, emphasizing their commitment to certified designs. Patrick Lahey, Triton's CEO, testified that he had warned Rush against using carbon fiber for deep dives, calling it "unproven and dangerous." The hearing has thus become a forum not just for accountability but for industry reform.

As proceedings continue, the world watches closely. The Titan's story is a stark reminder that the ocean's mysteries, while captivating, demand respect and humility. No vest, no matter how bright, can shield against the abyss if the vessel itself is flawed. (Word count: 1,248)

Read the Full KIRO Article at:
[ https://www.yahoo.com/news/bright-blue-vest-not-good-003419802.html ]