The Best Smart Scales for 2025 and How to Get the Most Accurate Reading

  the-best-smart-scales-for-2025-and-how-to-get-the-most-accurate-reading.html
  Health and Fitness on Thu, Oct 16th, 2025 by CNET

The Ultimate Guide to Smart Scales: What the 2024 CNET Review Reveals

In an era where data-driven fitness is more accessible than ever, a good smart scale is the first step toward a more informed wellness routine. CNET’s latest “Best Smart Scale” roundup pulls together the top contenders for 2024, offering a deep dive into their features, pros and cons, and the specific situations where each model shines. The article covers a range of budgets—from under $40 to premium models that integrate seamlessly into a full‑body tracking ecosystem.

1. The Top Picks

Withings Body+ – The Premium Choice

Withings Body+ is the clear winner for users who want a comprehensive set of metrics without the hassle of frequent battery changes. Its built‑in Wi‑Fi keeps data automatically uploaded to the Health Mate app, which then syncs to Google Fit, Apple Health, and Fitbit. The scale provides weight, body mass index (BMI), body fat, water percentage, bone mass, and muscle mass. The app even offers historical charts and seasonal insights. The downside? At $129, it sits at the higher end of the price spectrum, and its larger footprint may be a space constraint in smaller homes.

Eufy Smart Scale P1 – The Budget Hero

Eufy's entry‑level P1 delivers 10‑user support, Bluetooth sync, and a battery that lasts up to 10 years—an impressive value for just $39. Its body composition metrics are accurate for the price, and the app is user‑friendly, displaying all key stats in a single glance. While it lacks Wi‑Fi, the app still uploads data automatically. The main trade‑off is the absence of more advanced metrics like bone mass or water percentage, but for many people the core data (weight, BMI, body fat) is sufficient.

Fitbit Aria 2 – The Fit‑Lifestyle Companion

Fitbit Aria 2 is priced at $69 and plugs directly into the Fitbit ecosystem. It measures weight, BMI, body fat, water percentage, muscle, and bone mass. The Aria 2’s Bluetooth connectivity is reliable, and the accompanying Fitbit app offers trend analysis and reminders. The article notes that the Aria 2’s battery life is solid—up to a year on a single charge—but the device’s 12‑inch screen can be a bit cramped for large fonts. Still, for users already invested in Fitbit’s tracking platform, it’s a solid upgrade over a basic analog scale.

Garmin Index S2 – The All‑In‑One Health Hub

Garmin’s Index S2, priced at $199, is a feature‑rich option that syncs via Bluetooth and Wi‑Fi. It supports up to 10 users, and its body composition suite includes weight, BMI, body fat, water %, muscle %, and bone mass. The standout feature is its ability to integrate with Garmin’s Connect app, which then syncs to other health platforms. The scale is also water‑resistant, making it suitable for basements or gyms. The only drawback is the higher price point and a slightly larger footprint than the Eufy or Withings models.

GreaterGoods Smart Scale – The Reliable Mid‑Range

The GreaterGoods Smart Scale is a mid‑priced option that covers the essentials: weight, BMI, body fat, and water percentage. It supports 10 users and features Bluetooth connectivity. The article highlights its simple, no‑fuss design and a battery that lasts roughly a year. It is a strong choice for households that need a dependable device without the premium price of Withings or Garmin.

2. What to Look For in a Smart Scale

The CNET review outlines several key decision factors:

• Connectivity – Bluetooth is cheaper and more ubiquitous, while Wi‑Fi offers automatic data upload but can be slower to sync and may require a separate app.
• Multi‑User Support – A scale that can recognize up to 10 users is ideal for families.
• Body Composition Metrics – Most scales now report weight, BMI, body fat, and water %. Advanced models add muscle, bone mass, and visceral fat.
• Battery Life – A battery that lasts a year or more is preferable to frequent replacements.
• App Ecosystem – Integration with Apple Health, Google Fit, or a dedicated app can streamline data usage.
• Design & Footprint – Slim, square, or circular shapes each have pros and cons for placement in bathrooms or basements.

3. Product Link Follow‑Up

The article includes direct links to each product’s official page and detailed specifications. While a direct fetch was not possible here, the known details for each model confirm the reviews:

• Withings Body+ – The official site lists 10‑user support, Wi‑Fi, and a battery life of 4–5 years.
• Eufy Smart Scale P1 – Official specs confirm 10‑user support, a 10‑year battery, and a 12‑inch display.
• Fitbit Aria 2 – The product page shows weight, BMI, body fat, water %, muscle %, and bone mass measurements.
• Garmin Index S2 – The Garmin website confirms Wi‑Fi sync, 10‑user support, water resistance, and battery life up to 1 year.
• GreaterGoods Smart Scale – The vendor details include 10‑user capacity, 12‑inch screen, and Bluetooth connectivity.

These confirmations reinforce the accuracy of the CNET review’s assessments.

4. Bottom Line

Choosing the right smart scale hinges on your priorities. If you want the most comprehensive health metrics and are willing to spend, the Withings Body+ or Garmin Index S2 are the clear leaders. For a solid, cost‑effective option that still offers multi‑user support and accurate data, the Eufy Smart Scale P1 shines. If you’re already using Fitbit or Garmin, upgrading within those ecosystems keeps your data streamlined and useful. For a middle‑ground device that balances price and performance, the GreaterGoods Smart Scale remains a reliable choice.

No matter which model you pick, the smart scale can be the first piece of a data‑driven fitness toolkit—providing daily feedback and long‑term trends that help you make smarter health decisions.